One thing that strikes me in games is I can fight tough enemies until they are almost dead but they still fight and deal damage exactly the same as they did at 100% health. Ok that makes some sense with guns, although their accuracy should go down. But it doesn’t make sense for physical attacks.
Does anyone know of any games that reduce physical damage dealt based on health? And more importantly, does it work and is it fun?
Civ 5 units?
The first thing that comes to my head is Rock Em’ Sock Em’ Robots Arena, a PS1 robot fighting game. There are overall health bars for each robot like you would expect for most fighting games, but there is also a system for tracking damage to specific parts. Right arm, left arm, torso, head, and legs. If you focus damage to one part specifically, it is possible to disable or remove that part. If you manage to disable your opponent’s head, it is an automatic victory. If you disable an arm, the arm falls off and the opponent can no longer use it or its abilities. If you disable a part and win the match, you get to keep that part and can use it in your own robot (you can also use currency to buy these parts).
The problem from a gameplay perspective is that it’s snowbally. You can start off with a relatively even, challenging match, but once you knock off an arm the match gets really easy. In this case, they fixed it by making it pretty difficult to do. You really need to focus on the specific part you want to knock off or else you will just knock the opponent out and win the match.
Another example is the Banner Saga series. They have a system for both armor and health, where the more health a character has the more damage they do. It makes for a bunch of interesting strategic decisions around party composition, itemization, positioning, and ability usage. It also makes the battles more snowball-y. In this case I would say it is a good thing becsuse it makes the matches go faster and the games are designed around the mechanic.
The first thing that comes to my head is Rock Em’ Sock Em’ Robots Arena, a PS1 robot fighting game. There are overall health bars for each robot like you would expect for most fighting games, but there is also a system for tracking damage to specific parts. Right arm, left arm, torso, head, and legs. If you focus damage to one part specifically, it is possible to disable or remove that part. If you manage to disable your opponent’s head, it is an automatic victory. If you disable an arm, the arm falls off and the opponent can no longer use it or its abilities. If you disable a part and win the match, you get to keep that part and can use it in your own robot (you can also use currency to buy these parts).
The problem from a gameplay perspective is that it’s snowbally. You can start off with a relatively even, challenging match, but once you knock off an arm the match gets really easy. In this case, they fixed it by making it pretty difficult to do. You really need to focus on the specific part you want to knock off or else you will just knock the opponent out and win the match.
Another example is the Banner Saga series. They have a system for both armor and health, where the more health a character has the more damage they do. It makes for a bunch of interesting strategic decisions around party composition, itemization, positioning, and ability usage. It also makes the battles more snowball-y. In this case I would say it is a good thing becsuse it makes the matches go faster and the games are designed around the mechanic.
The first thing that comes to my head is Rock Em’ Sock Em’ Robots Arena, a PS1 robot fighting game. There are overall health bars for each robot like you would expect for most fighting games, but there is also a system for tracking damage to specific parts. Right arm, left arm, torso, head, and legs. If you focus damage to one part specifically, it is possible to disable or remove that part. If you manage to disable your opponent’s head, it is an automatic victory. If you disable an arm, the arm falls off and the opponent can no longer use it or its abilities. If you disable a part and win the match, you get to keep that part and can use it in your own robot (you can also use currency to buy these parts).
The problem from a gameplay perspective is that it’s snowbally. You can start off with a relatively even, challenging match, but once you knock off an arm the match gets really easy. In this case, they fixed it by making it pretty difficult to do. You really need to focus on the specific part you want to knock off or else you will just knock the opponent out and win the match.
Another example is the Banner Saga series. They have a system for both armor and health, where the more health a character has the more damage they do. It makes for a bunch of interesting strategic decisions around party composition, itemization, positioning, and ability usage. It also makes the battles more snowball-y. In this case I would say it is a good thing becsuse it makes the matches go faster and the games are designed around the mechanic.
In borderlands, when you are fighting for your life aiming becomes quite difficult. Not sure that meets the criterion and it doesn’t seem to apply to the enemy.
Bit different, but: check out the old PlayStation game ‘Bushido Blade’: it’s a ‘realistic’ samurai game where one slash with a weapon can kill. It has both a one-on-one fighting mode, and a beat-em-up adventure mode.
I’ve also heard of and seen more-modern sword fighting games with the same approach, but don’t remember the titles.
That looks pretty cool!
Came here to say Bushido Blade, but it should be mentioned that non-fatal hits will cripple the limb they strike, and your fighter can end up crawling around unable to attack if everything’s been struck but a deathblow.
Vanquish has several enemies like that. You can hit them in the legs/arms/guns to progressively cripple them, reducing their HP and making them easier to kill.
I really loved that game, had a unique feeling to it.
Dark Souls 3
The Pontiff Beasts get a damage debuff if you manage to get them down to like a tiny sliver of hp but don’t kill them. They also will cower in fear for a moment and limp pathetically until you finish them off.
The latter is also a staple in the whole Dark Souls series. There is the Red Tear Stone Ring that increases your damage at low health, and the Blue Tear Stone Ring that raises your defense at low health.
Tunic also takes that mechanic from DS and uses it nicely with a ring and some other items to make you into a devestating glass cannon that can one shot almost anything at the cost of only having 1 hit yourself.
To a higher extreme, Dwarf Fortress has so many ways of being hurt that also make you weaker. Losing limbs, having your fat and skin melt off, being weakened by poisons or gasses, etc.
I mean in many they do more as they lose health. All the same are you fine with the player character having the same mechanic?
In Kingdom Come: Deliverance (1 and 2) being injured limits your stamina which prevents you from attacking as many times in a row. This applies to both the player and to enemies. These games also only have a limited healing system, only restoring health over time and not being able to use healing items in active combat, which makes it more important to plan ahead and be prepared. I think this works well as making a mistake punishes you by making it easy to get overwhelmed, even once you get to a higher level and have good gear. It also rewards slower play as putting an arrow or three into a group of enemies before they get to you gives you a huge advantage, especially if you are outnumbered.
Only cases where the strength goes justifiably down I can remember are Final Fantasy VII (OG), Naruto Storm 4, and Evening Starter’s respective final fights.
About FFVII...
The “final” fight is a scripted fight against an 1 HP Sephiroth, I’d imagine Sephiroth being as weak on this last fight for maybe being the remnants of his consciousness given form after the fight where he dies.
About Storm 4...
Same with the manga and anime, after the villain defeated, Naruto and Sasuke still have some unresolved disputes, and keep fighting until way past they can use any powers, the final stretch being a sloppy brawl where both of them can barely move anymore.
About Evening Starter...
First, don’t look it up, at least publicly. It’s a horror and eroge game.
Second, the final fight is also scripted, like with FFVII, though in it both the protagonist and the villain barely alive after surviving a falling building. The villain too weak to be able to properly shoot at the protagonist, and the protagonist with several bones broken and having to slowly drag her hand that still somewhat works throughout the turns to a loaded gun she keeps with her.
And considering how the game’s lore is rather fucked up, pun not intended, it’s very hard to know what’s going to happen.
In all cases, I think it works pretty well.
However, for a more open battle, only case I can remember, but barely fitting, is…
a boss from Persona 5.
Shido’s Shadow iirc is one of the bosses with the most health in the game, and with the most unique stages since iirc Persona 3’s original final boss. However, he barely fits because in the stage he gets “weaker”, the final stage, he’s about as strong as the previous stage, but his animation loop showing him getting so exhausted he can barely keep his arms in a lifted stance, implying his doing an effort to keep up while being at his limit.
In a lore perspective, it also works well imo, though not actually fitting a weakened enemy into gameplay.
The Banner Saga is a turn based game that has an interesting take on this. You can attack both armor and HP, and armor acts to reduce HP damage. So you want to wear armor down, then take out a big chunk of HP when they’re exposed.
On top of that, health dictates damage, so you sort of have to decide how many turns of taking full damage you can risk stripping their armor before you go for HP damage.
I quite liked the game, and the story was really good too, though I haven’t tried the sequel yet.
Works really well in Wargroove.
EFT, just play it with SPT.
Gesundheit
Lol, ok that’s fair. Other guy nailed it though. It’s offline single player tarkov. Tons of mods for it as well, and if you got friends, you can even run project fika and play coop. Mods and all.
It’s a lot of fun and you don’t have to deal with the cheaters in efts pvp servers.
Ok so I had to look it up, Escape from Tarkov, with a single player mod
Pretty much any Fallout from 3 on
Kenshi
The Flood in the first Halo trilogy’s arms can be shot off so they can’t really deal damage; at least in the first two games.
The Surge games have directional/limb targeting, so you could theoretically take off limbs before you kill them.





