Some GTA 6 physical buyers say their boxes came with no download code or one already redeemed, and with no disc inside, they can't install the game at all.
Not if you don’t care about putting the game on the drive. It’s already obsolete by the time the user gets the game box, and they always require Day 1 patches to be functional anyway. Just ignore needing to include the game on the stick entirely. Enough space for a license key would only need a few MB, and it doesn’t need to be particularly robust stuff either, it could be permanently read-only.
Use the USB stick as a physical license key/token. Because nothing is actually run from the discs anyway once installed, the system already checks for a corresponding disc, then it looks for a stored license on the console, and if one is missing it checks the user’s account for a license. So you just adjust that first physical check to look for either the corresponding disc or USB key.
The problem with the license key dongle idea is that it projects outside the device, and it could lead to damage by younger ones. It could be a micro usb dongle encased in a figurine or something, which could add to the release collectible, and it could “snap off” if clipped by kids running around being stupid.
The problem with the license key dongle idea is that it projects outside the device, and it could lead to damage by younger ones.
You could say the same about controller wires or even memory cards on previous consoles. That’s not a very good excuse.
It’s as big or small as you want to make it. There are a ton of tiny USB dongles that are a fraction of an inch long. Basically every wireless keyboard, mouse, and controller that use a 2,4GHz signal (not bluetooth) come with a tiny dongle like this now.
Even smaller potentially if they want to use USB-C instead of USB-A ports. If they choose to make them bigger or more complicated for sales or collectibles, that’s a possibility. But strictly as a replacement for disc licenses, nothing bigger than that is needed, maybe just a bit more to show the box art or something. Heck, they could even allow it plug into the controller charging port.
That entirely defeats the purpose of physical media imo.
How so? The info on the disc now doesn’t let you play the game anyway. At most, it makes the initial download and install take a little less time.
Take a brand new PS5, pop the disc in with no internet connection, and you still can’t play the game because it needs at least a day 1 patch to enable it to work anyway. Why even pretend a playable game is actually there? The disc is just a license already.
Doesn’t really matter when it started, that was 20 years ago. It’s here and it’s never going away. Complaining about it is a waste of time and energy that’s much more useful handling new issues you can still effect.
Yes yes yes, typical gamer response. everythings horrible but we just have to accept it and keep shoveling money to game companies, because how dare I be expected to speak with my wallet and not have my precious shiny.
Problems just need to be fixed without me lifting a finger or suffering the indignity of not having everything i want when i want it.
we just have to accept it and keep shoveling money to game companies
We don’t have to do anything of the sort. Just don’t buy games from shitty companies. It’s not very hard.
Either don’t play them at all, or pirate them. Take advantage of the nearing thousands of PC recomp projects to play those console exclusives on a regular PC. If you do want to support the developers, buy more directly if possible, or through something like GOG where there is no DRM.
Most indie studios aren’t fucking over players, that’s mostly a AAA studio thing. And their games are quickly becoming less enjoyable anyway as they kill off beloved studios and abandon IPs in the process.
This is on purpose so they can gatekeep computing and keep it being hyper capitalistic instead of letting it get more left wing like open source was threatening
You are both right. There currently is no good way out of this mess other than trying to keep together what we already own somehow. And only installing DRM free software on those drives. Or, you know, software that was made DRM free by Good Samaritans.
Well with the current NAND shortage those would cost about 500$ each or something
Not if you don’t care about putting the game on the drive. It’s already obsolete by the time the user gets the game box, and they always require Day 1 patches to be functional anyway. Just ignore needing to include the game on the stick entirely. Enough space for a license key would only need a few MB, and it doesn’t need to be particularly robust stuff either, it could be permanently read-only.
Use the USB stick as a physical license key/token. Because nothing is actually run from the discs anyway once installed, the system already checks for a corresponding disc, then it looks for a stored license on the console, and if one is missing it checks the user’s account for a license. So you just adjust that first physical check to look for either the corresponding disc or USB key.
The problem with the license key dongle idea is that it projects outside the device, and it could lead to damage by younger ones. It could be a micro usb dongle encased in a figurine or something, which could add to the release collectible, and it could “snap off” if clipped by kids running around being stupid.
You could say the same about controller wires or even memory cards on previous consoles. That’s not a very good excuse.
It’s as big or small as you want to make it. There are a ton of tiny USB dongles that are a fraction of an inch long. Basically every wireless keyboard, mouse, and controller that use a 2,4GHz signal (not bluetooth) come with a tiny dongle like this now.
https://media.piefed.social/posts/l7/fO/l7fOxnBa5Ud4hWO.png
Even smaller potentially if they want to use USB-C instead of USB-A ports. If they choose to make them bigger or more complicated for sales or collectibles, that’s a possibility. But strictly as a replacement for disc licenses, nothing bigger than that is needed, maybe just a bit more to show the box art or something. Heck, they could even allow it plug into the controller charging port.
That entirely defeats the purpose of physical media imo. But then I haven’t used a console since the PS3 so I’m not exactly the target audience here.
How so? The info on the disc now doesn’t let you play the game anyway. At most, it makes the initial download and install take a little less time.
Take a brand new PS5, pop the disc in with no internet connection, and you still can’t play the game because it needs at least a day 1 patch to enable it to work anyway. Why even pretend a playable game is actually there? The disc is just a license already.
That is a more recent thing. I think that also defeats the purpose of it. To me if it needs the internet to work its useless.
the whole “ship it broken and patch it later” bullshit only started with the always online internet connected era.
Games were capable of being shipped, without being patched, for far longer than that, and rarely had any game breaking bugs.
Doesn’t really matter when it started, that was 20 years ago. It’s here and it’s never going away. Complaining about it is a waste of time and energy that’s much more useful handling new issues you can still effect.
Yes yes yes, typical gamer response. everythings horrible but we just have to accept it and keep shoveling money to game companies, because how dare I be expected to speak with my wallet and not have my precious shiny.
Problems just need to be fixed without me lifting a finger or suffering the indignity of not having everything i want when i want it.
We don’t have to do anything of the sort. Just don’t buy games from shitty companies. It’s not very hard.
Either don’t play them at all, or pirate them. Take advantage of the nearing thousands of PC recomp projects to play those console exclusives on a regular PC. If you do want to support the developers, buy more directly if possible, or through something like GOG where there is no DRM.
Most indie studios aren’t fucking over players, that’s mostly a AAA studio thing. And their games are quickly becoming less enjoyable anyway as they kill off beloved studios and abandon IPs in the process.
This is on purpose so they can gatekeep computing and keep it being hyper capitalistic instead of letting it get more left wing like open source was threatening
You are both right. There currently is no good way out of this mess other than trying to keep together what we already own somehow. And only installing DRM free software on those drives. Or, you know, software that was made DRM free by Good Samaritans.