Okay so yes, I’m vegan and I don’t love PETAs tactics and some of their practices are not the same choices I would make. I’m going to leave it at that, I will not debate carnists about PETA. Just like I try not to criticise leftist movements in non-leftist spaces and will focus on specific elements and not write them off entirely.
I do think a variety of tactics is important, just like in leftist movements. It takes a lot of different approaches to tackle these huge systemic problems. No one is making me do street theater. I can choose not to like it or think it’s effective. But it doesn’t mean it never reaches anyone or that people don’t enjoy that outlet.
Edit: I should probably explain how that connects lol - so even if I don’t like it and people think it gives vegans a bad image, I don’t think the meme is literally true. People will take issue with even the mildest perceived criticism. I am very careful to not discuss it in some circumstances but if someone asks for dietary restraints and I answer sometimes even that makes them defensive. You can’t win.
Someone once pointed out to me that if non-vegans’ critiques of how PETA operates actually worked to further PETA’s goals, those making the critiques wouldn’t be non-vegans
That sounds like a textbook example of confirmation bias 😅 It also ignores the idea that it takes a lot of different tactics to reach different people.
I do know people who were swayed by PETA and I think those are the folks who end up taking that approach themselves. They might not immediately jump into it, but they do it because it worked on them.
Conversely, that’s why I focus on antispeciesm and that it isn’t some giant sacrifice.
One of the important tactics to reach different people is not to use derogatory names like “carnists” to describe them. Even if you have a good point to make, I am less likely to listen to you if you’re calling me names.
The whole idea of a multitude of tactics is that some tactics work on some people and other tactics work on other people. I know of many people who wouldn’t pay attention to any criticism if they were being coddled and their oppressive behavior being tiptoed around, whereas being ridiculed and called names that accurately describe their unexamined cruelty and hypocrisy is what actually gets through to them.
Also, maybe you deserve to be called those names and it’s the silent witnesses seeing the “debate” who are the ones whose minds are being changed. There’s a real self-centered arrogance to assume that when your hypocrisy is being called out that it’s because those calling it out are trying to change your mind as an individual, and even worse to think that you deserve to be babied and pampered into doing so.
Okay so yes, I’m vegan and I don’t love PETAs tactics and some of their practices are not the same choices I would make. I’m going to leave it at that, I will not debate carnists about PETA. Just like I try not to criticise leftist movements in non-leftist spaces and will focus on specific elements and not write them off entirely.
I do think a variety of tactics is important, just like in leftist movements. It takes a lot of different approaches to tackle these huge systemic problems. No one is making me do street theater. I can choose not to like it or think it’s effective. But it doesn’t mean it never reaches anyone or that people don’t enjoy that outlet.
Edit: I should probably explain how that connects lol - so even if I don’t like it and people think it gives vegans a bad image, I don’t think the meme is literally true. People will take issue with even the mildest perceived criticism. I am very careful to not discuss it in some circumstances but if someone asks for dietary restraints and I answer sometimes even that makes them defensive. You can’t win.
Someone once pointed out to me that if non-vegans’ critiques of how PETA operates actually worked to further PETA’s goals, those making the critiques wouldn’t be non-vegans
That sounds like a textbook example of confirmation bias 😅 It also ignores the idea that it takes a lot of different tactics to reach different people.
I do know people who were swayed by PETA and I think those are the folks who end up taking that approach themselves. They might not immediately jump into it, but they do it because it worked on them.
Conversely, that’s why I focus on antispeciesm and that it isn’t some giant sacrifice.
One of the important tactics to reach different people is not to use derogatory names like “carnists” to describe them. Even if you have a good point to make, I am less likely to listen to you if you’re calling me names.
“Carnist” is derogatory? From an etymological analysis, it seems rather apt
The whole idea of a multitude of tactics is that some tactics work on some people and other tactics work on other people. I know of many people who wouldn’t pay attention to any criticism if they were being coddled and their oppressive behavior being tiptoed around, whereas being ridiculed and called names that accurately describe their unexamined cruelty and hypocrisy is what actually gets through to them.
Also, maybe you deserve to be called those names and it’s the silent witnesses seeing the “debate” who are the ones whose minds are being changed. There’s a real self-centered arrogance to assume that when your hypocrisy is being called out that it’s because those calling it out are trying to change your mind as an individual, and even worse to think that you deserve to be babied and pampered into doing so.
Famously we didn’t do mean things like “name calling” to slave owners and Nazi slaughterhouse officers and they listened and stopped being bad.
spoiler
Just kidding! STFU and be better, asshole.
Carnist sounds sick as hell tho.