Give me the Death Note, I can be trusted to act rationally. The only “undeserving” to end up on it would be people who step through Metro doors and immediately stop, even though there’s people behind them.

More seriously I know the author has said it’s about power corrupting, but if that’s the story he wanted to tell then he should’ve chosen a different protagonist. Its also a silly mantra, we do not live in a Tolkien novel, power isn’t some supernatural force.

  • AnyOldName3@lemmy.world
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    0
    ·
    8 days ago

    Watching this as a teenager, I pretty much immediately realised that there was nothing in the mechanics of the Death Note stopping you from saying people died of old age having lived an ethical and fulfilling life free from crime after <the date the entry was written>. The real power of the Death Note was in the apparently unlimited ability to set the conditions of death, and it was barely used.

    • ttayh@lemmy.zip
      link
      fedilink
      arrow-up
      0
      ·
      8 days ago

      There is,

      • you can only control the victim’s actions for like 3 months
      • you cannot extend life
      • AnyOldName3@lemmy.world
        link
        fedilink
        arrow-up
        0
        ·
        8 days ago

        I just looked it up on the wiki, and the closest thing I can find is the 23-day rule, which isn’t mentioned in the anime, and only adds the condition that if you specify a specific time within 23 days and specific disease that wouldn’t be fatal in the timeframe you specified, it defaults to a heart attack. If you specify a disease that takes over 23 days to develop and no specific time, then the disease will progress starting when you write at its natural speed. Old age as a cause with no date seems to fit the latter category.

        • milbyte@lemmy.ml
          link
          fedilink
          arrow-up
          0
          ·
          8 days ago

          i wouldn’t say that “old age” is a disease. it’s a state where actual diseases can kill you way easier, their incubation time would probably be lower than normal in that case.

          but you could probably go for something like HIV which takes 1-10 years and might be fatal, especially if untreated.

          • AnyOldName3@lemmy.world
            link
            fedilink
            arrow-up
            0
            ·
            8 days ago

            After 39 days, you’re visited by your Shinigami, and can ask them for help workshopping how to phrase dies of some disease that can’t happen until they’re old so the auto-selected date is some point where they’re already old, but if they were already going to die before that, dying at their predestined time of an accident or disease is fine, too.

            • shneancy@lemmy.world
              link
              fedilink
              arrow-up
              0
              ·
              7 days ago

              if your victim can’t die in the way you specified within 23 days then they get a heart attack. if you don’t specify a death time then 23 days after the entry that person is out of the note’s jurisdiction. you can’t just @everyone live long and be kind

              unless you decide to nuke the planet and the period of “long and kind” covers only the 23 days pre nuke

              • AnyOldName3@lemmy.world
                link
                fedilink
                arrow-up
                0
                ·
                7 days ago

                That’s not supported by the disease rule. The 23 day rule would suggest you’re limited:

                If you write, “die of disease” for the cause of death, but only write a specific time of death without the actual name of disease, the human will die from an adequate disease. But the Death Note can only operate within 23 days (in the human calendar). This is called the 23-day rule.

                but the disease rule overrides it:

                If you write, “die of disease” like before with a specific disease’s name, but without a specific time, if it takes more than 24 days for the human to die the 23-day rule will not take effect and the human will die at an adequate time depending on the disease.

                The only duration limitation within the actual rules is one where instructions to opt out of it are provided.

    • BanMeFromPosting@lemmy.mlOP
      link
      fedilink
      arrow-up
      0
      ·
      8 days ago

      The conditions weren’t unlimited and you could not exceed 30 days from when you wrote the name, if you did they’d just die of a heart attack.
      You could not make the person do something that was far outside their character (like make Bezos give up all his money). But then again that seemed to get dropped since he made the FBI lady go straight home and off herself. Then again that rule was just what Light believed it to be, so the author has some cover there.

        • BanMeFromPosting@lemmy.mlOP
          link
          fedilink
          arrow-up
          0
          ·
          edit-2
          8 days ago

          Its not the suicide that’s the bit, its the “getting told who Kira is and doing nothing about it” thats the un characteristic bit.

          There’s also this

          Neither suicide nor accidental death can cause a death that directly results in the death of anyone other than the person whose name is written. If it would cause the death of another human being, it would be a heart attack under circumstances where the person named would not cause the death of a third party."

          So thats another limit i suppose.

          It also says a human can’t use the Death Note to extend their lifespan, but then again it also states that

          The use of the Death Note in the human world sometimes affects other humans’ lives or shortens their original life span, even though their names are not actually written in the Death Note itself.

          So it kind of seems like the author is making it up as they go along. Its been a while since I read it as well and I remember something about a time limit, but now its not there, so I guess thats just Nelsom Mandela hitting me with those dimensional rays

          edit: found this for you

          You cannot set a death date longer than the victim’s original lifespan. Even if the victim’s death is entered in the Death Note, if it is beyond his or her original lifespan, the victim will die before the set time.

          And then theres also the thing about “old age” not being a cause of death

          • AnyOldName3@lemmy.world
            link
            fedilink
            arrow-up
            0
            ·
            8 days ago

            After your first go, you just need to wait 39 days and your Shinigami appears, and you can ask them questions which they have to answer to the best of their ability (which isn’t guaranteed to give you the full detail, as they might not know it). That should give you a good opportunity to workshop exactly how to phrase dies of some disease that can’t happen until they’re old so the auto-selected date is some point where they’re already old, but if they were already going to die before that, dying at their predestined time of an accident or disease is fine, too and make it work.

            I did see that there’s another tab to the article that phrases the 23-day rule differently, stopping you set death times further in the future than that, but then immediately explains how death times after that work for diseases, so that’s obviously self-contradictory.

            • BanMeFromPosting@lemmy.mlOP
              link
              fedilink
              arrow-up
              0
              ·
              edit-2
              7 days ago

              There’s no disease you can only get when you’re old, people get arthritis at the age of 25. Old age just makes you more likely to get a bunch of different ailments, but they are always possible.
              And there’s still the rule about not extending the lifespan, so you still wont extend your life, you’ll just die at the predestined point

              • AnyOldName3@lemmy.world
                link
                fedilink
                arrow-up
                0
                ·
                7 days ago

                Plenty of diseases have age-related in the name, and definitionally only happen to old people, with the variant affecting younger people being given a different name and often having a different trigger. If the Death Note respects human understanding of medical science, then if you specify the age-related variant of the disease, you can be confident it’ll wait. If there are any nuances, you can ask the Shinigami.

                • BanMeFromPosting@lemmy.mlOP
                  link
                  fedilink
                  arrow-up
                  0
                  ·
                  6 days ago

                  There are no diseases you can only get after having lived a certain number of years.
                  There’s plenty of diseases that predominantly affects the elderly, due to their bodies and immune system being weaker, but there are plenty of cases with young people having “definitionally” elderly ailments.
                  And, again, you’d still just die at your allotted time.