queermunist she/her

Nah

  • 0 Posts
  • 81 Comments
Joined 3 years ago
cake
Cake day: July 10th, 2023

help-circle
  • Yes, companies often refuse to hire people with felony convictions. And yes, Black Americans are disproportionately represented in the prison population. However, those two facts, by themselves, don’t establish that hiring practices are responsible for the broader income disparities between racial groups, nor do they substantiate your argument about nepotism.

    My point is that these things are all playing a role together. It’s just another example of how non-racist hiring managers could still produce racial disparities because they are working within a racist system. The hiring practices of companies disqualify many Black people because of racist policing, and that’s related to how nepotism favors white people because they’re more likely to have family high up in the company that can give them a job, and that’s related to how generational wealth compounds leading to white people owning these companies in the first place. It’s all an interconnected system of racism.

    And so you can have racist outcomes in hiring, without the hiring managers actually being racists.



  • Okay so something I don’t think you’re appreciating is that racial hiring preferences don’t literally only mean that the hiring managers have racism in their hearts or something. A company with racial hiring practices isn’t necessarily run by racists!

    The nepotism, the generational wealth, these things play a role in creating structural racism. A society that has racist outcomes, even if the people involved are not necessarily racists. Another example:

    Let’s say you’re a hiring manager. You don’t want to hire anyone who has had trouble with the police, that’s just company policy. However, if you live in a society where police target Black people, that means they’re more likely to have police records. The end result: you hire fewer Black people. This, in effect, is a racial hiring practice. The hiring manger isn’t racist, the societal structures are.



  • And you think that’s the only reason? It’s really not. You seem to be ignoring that white people are overrepresented in positions of power and wealth, even above what their proportion of the population would predict. Why do you think that is?

    Wealth is also heritable, and a lot of white people inherited wealth their families gained from stealing land and owning slaves. They grew that wealth during periods of racial segregation and that wealth doesn’t just go away because Black people can vote. Wealth also compounds over lifetimes and over generations, so if whites started out ahead, they’re going to tend to stay ahead.

    I’m just pointing out how racism can be structural, without individual people involved being racists.


  • What you’re overlooking, however, is nepotism and just how pervasive a problem it can be. People aren’t always hiring someone because that person is the most qualified candidate. They’re hiring friends, family members, acquaintances, and people within their personal networks. In those situations, merit can become secondary to personal relationships.

    Nepotism and racial discrimination are actually related. White people tend to have more positions of power than what their percentage of the population should predict, and then they hire their white families and white friends because our society is still somewhat segregated. This still leads to white people getting more opportunities and better jobs for reasons other than merit.