• 1 Post
  • 58 Comments
Joined 3 years ago
cake
Cake day: June 27th, 2023

help-circle
  • My experience with KDE is that it is a frustrating new user experience. I also doubt that the devs have tried setting up their desktop from defaults recently.

    Kwallet (one of the two reasons I stopped using KDE): Kwallets defaults are bad. They encourage you down an opaque path that requires CLI intervention. If you stubbornly take that path the performance of kwallet is painfully bad. Any electron app (discord, etc.) will now hang unresponsive on the main UI thread for 1 to 3 minutes if kwallet was not already open. None of these apps need kwallet. Chromium stalls in the same way on startup except that if you don’t want to open the wallet it will keep asking 3-4 times taking minutes to reach the prompt each time and won’t unblock the main UI thread until you either enter the password or it crashes with an error that too many wallet requests were issued. Protonvpn won’t open on KDE unless a wallet is configured and unlocked. The password prompt has a time out for no cryptographically good reason which means if you try to open the wallet and then wind up distracted by something else you may time out and need to restart the waiting game from square one. Bugs have been open against kwallet for years. Allegedly they have been fixed and I have updated but the speed is still awful on my computer.

    Fractional scaling: Nominally KDE does this the “right” way but practically application support seems somewhat absent. The flagship Linux office product, Libre Office, displays microscopically on one monitor with fractional scaling on. It just works on other DEs

    Borderless fullscreen with mouse capture on multiple monitors is broken and results in the mouse wandering off and going MIA in FPS style games. KDE killed me in Helldivers several times before I switched windowing modes. Honestly minor except that it seems to be the default in gaming distros where this matters

    Other DE issues:

    • Cinnamon freezes on haswell age Intel iGPs
    • XFCE handles cheap Chinese graphics tablets badly
    • XFCE fractional scaling is confusing and requires updating too many settings. The flip side of this is it can run fractional scaling much more performantly than other DEs under x11 on lousy iGPs. The problem here is not that the scaling controls are inverted but that the graphics scale settings are scattered all over the place.

    All in all I would say that Cinnamon is a lot less frustrating at an entry level than KDE on recent hardware.



  • People want a console but also:

    • A wider game library (Missing on Playstation and Xbox)
    • No subscription (missing Playstation and Xbox)
    • a working 10 foot UI (missing in windows)
    • controller os navigation (missing in windows)
    • no bimonthly fullscreen nags to use edge, office365, onedrive, etc. (missing in windows)
    • Working ACPI sleep states. (Missing on most cheap mini PCs)
    • Backwards compatibility for older titles and not needing to rebuy games when upgrading (Missing on PlayStation)

    Microsoft could probably build an XBox that fixes the first problem but would probably fill it with nag screens.

    People with technical skills can probably run Bazzite on a minipc but might hit issues with sleep depending on luck while purchasing.

    People without technical skills just want a package that works