• 1 Post
  • 1.19K Comments
Joined 3 years ago
cake
Cake day: November 14th, 2023

help-circle
  • No, you don’t have to install a different distro.

    Ubuntu ships with Gnome. That you can change it is actually the point I was making.

    I replied to this:

    respect for the user, consistency, customisability,"

    With the statement that consistency is often at odds with customizability.

    Your claim was this:

    It’s almost like any app on any operating system is going to have a different gui!

    Windows apps do not have as much inconsistency as apps on Linux because of the lack of customizablity. A Windows developer has to go out of their way to avoid the standard Windows libraries to make their app look unique. Linux apps are all different because there is no way to make them consistent. Even if you try to make your app consistent in say Gnome, someone is going to be running KDE.

    Consistency is almost always at odd with customizability.



  • I have argued that vlans do very little for home users.

    Vlans with firewall rules mean that every room in your house has a rule that you have to go out the locked front door before going back into another room. But if an external threat can bypass the front lock, having a rule that everyone inside has to use the front lock does nothing. Either the front lock works in which case everything is safe or it doesn’t work in which case the rule to use the front door lock every time you go from inside room to inside room does nothing.








  • Saving a file to a folder of your choice

    What program are you seeing that?

    I use Linux and Windows and don’t see that. I just checked with saving a file in the Windows version of Orca (3d slicer), Save brings up the standard Windows dialog that has all the folders on the left panel and the contents of the currently selected folder on the right panel. It’s virtually identical to the Save dialog box of Orca under Ubuntu right down to dividing local directories on top of the left panel and network share on the bottom left.

    That’s the default Save in Windows. A program has to go out of its way to avoid the standard Windows Save dialog box which is the same problem Linux programs can have.




  • , it said that it was repealed and superseded in the 70s.

    It absolutely did not say that.

    17 U.S.C. § 109(a) from 1976 clarified the earlier laws without changing them at all. It even specifically mentions video games. That is if you buy a video game you have the right to resell it (dispose).

    Courts have since ruled that the law and 17 U.S.C. § 109(a) don’t apply because you bought a “license”.

    But that doesn’t change the law or 17 U.S.C. § 109(a) which was even clearer that someone who purchases music or a video game has the right to resell it.

    Court rulings aren’t law.



  • The law you linked is 100 years old

    Laws don’t expire unless specifically written to expire. Do you not believe in the right to free speech because that law is 250 years old?

    Nor was it superceded 50 years ago. The case was in 2012 and wasn’t ruled until 2018.

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Capitol_Records,_LLC_v._ReDigi_Inc.

    because you’re making a copy (which first sale doctrine does not allow you to do)

    You aren’t necessarily making a copy. You are transferring a license to use. Steam restricts duplicate license usage.

    The law was about digital copies of music without DRM. Given that Steam restricts duplicate licenses, that court ruling doesn’t necessarily apply. And a court ruling isn’t a law. That’s why I claim Steam is breaking the law. But they get away with it because they have the billions to sue anyone who fights for the legal rights. So no one has tried.



  • people with organ transplants don’t own the organs they bought.

    You didn’t buy the organ you got transplanted because federal law prohibits all organ sales.

    TIL people with pacemakers don’t own their hearts.

    ??? A pacemaker is device implanted to maintain regular rhythm. If you purchased one from the manufacturer, you could sell it to someone else.

    “Only multi player content”

    So content was removed.